PayPal vs Square UK 2026: Fees, Features & Which to Choose

Updated November 2026

Compare Card Processing Rates & Save
Trusted by 10,000+ UK businesses

PayPal and Square are two of the most recognised payment providers available to UK small businesses in 2026, but they suit very different needs. PayPal is strongest for online and e-commerce businesses that want a trusted checkout brand and the ability to accept payments from more than 200 countries. Square is better suited to physical retail, hospitality, and service businesses that need a free card reader, a built-in point-of-sale system, and free next-business-day settlement. Both charge no monthly fee on their entry-level plans. Neither locks you into a long-term contract.

Key Facts

PayPalSquare
Founded19982009
UK launchEarly 2000s2017
FCA statusFCA authorised e-money institution (PayPal UK Ltd, FRN 994790)FCA authorised e-money institution (Squareup Europe Ltd, FRN 900846)
In-person transaction fee1.75% per transaction (Zettle Reader)1.75% per transaction (free plan)
Online transaction fee2.9% + £0.30 per transaction (standard checkout)1.4% + 25p per transaction (UK cards)
Monthly fee£0 (standard plan)£0 (free plan)
Contract lengthRolling monthly, no minimum termRolling monthly, no minimum term
Settlement speed1 to 2 business days standard; instant for 1.5% fee (min 25p, max £15)Next business day, free of charge

Who Is This Page For?

This page is for UK small business owners comparing PayPal and Square before choosing a payment provider. It is particularly relevant if you run a retail shop, café, restaurant, market stall, or e-commerce store and want to understand which provider costs less for your specific sales mix. It is also useful if you currently use one of these providers and are wondering whether switching would save money. If you process more than £100,000 per month, you will likely outgrow both platforms and should also read the best merchant accounts for small businesses in the UK guide.

Key Takeaways

  • Square and PayPal Zettle both charge 1.75% per in-person transaction on their standard plans, so there is no fee difference between the two for in-person card acceptance.
  • PayPal online transactions cost 2.9% plus a £0.30 fixed fee for standard checkout in the UK. That makes it more expensive for high-volume e-commerce than Stripe (1.5% plus 20p) or Shopify Payments.
  • Square settles funds the next business day at no charge. PayPal offers instant transfers for a 1.5% fee (minimum 25p, maximum £15) or standard settlement in one to two business days.
  • Both providers operate on rolling monthly contracts with no early termination fees on standard plans.
  • Square's free POS software includes inventory management, employee timecards, and sales reporting. PayPal's Zettle equivalent is simpler and less suited to inventory-heavy retail.
  • Both providers are regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority as electronic money institutions. Neither offers FSCS deposit protection.
  • Account freezes are a known risk with both platforms. Neither operates a dedicated merchant account, so your account can be suspended with limited notice if their risk systems flag activity.

PayPal vs Square: Fee Comparison

FeaturePayPalSquare
In-person transaction fee1.75% per transaction (Zettle Reader)1.75% per transaction (free plan)
Online transaction fee2.9% + £0.30 per transaction (standard checkout)1.4% + 25p per online UK card transaction (2.5% + 25p for non-UK cards)
Monthly fee£0 (standard plan)£0 (free plan); Square for Retail Plus from £49/month
Contract lengthRolling monthly, no minimum termRolling monthly, no minimum term
Settlement speed1 to 2 business days standard; instant for 1.5% (min 25p, max £15)Next business day, free of charge
FCA regulatedYes. PayPal UK Ltd, FCA authorised e-money institution (FRN 994790)Yes. Squareup Europe Ltd, FCA authorised e-money institution (FRN 900846)
Card reader costZettle Reader 2 from £29 + VAT (first reader)Square Reader from £19 + VAT (first reader)
Best forOnline and e-commerce businesses, international sellersPhysical retail, hospitality, mobile traders

What Is PayPal?

PayPal is a global online payments platform founded in 1998 and used by more than 400 million active accounts worldwide. In the UK, it operates as a payment service provider for both online checkouts and in-person payments through its Zettle point-of-sale product, acquired in 2018. UK businesses can accept credit cards, debit cards, PayPal wallet payments, and Buy Now Pay Later through PayPal Pay Later, all under one account. PayPal UK Ltd is authorised by the FCA as an electronic money institution (FRN 994790).

The core appeal of PayPal for UK merchants is brand recognition at checkout. Research consistently shows that displaying the PayPal button increases online conversion rates, partly because buyers trust the platform and partly because they can pay without entering card details. That advantage is most valuable for online retailers and digital services businesses. For a full breakdown of fees and features, read the PayPal UK review on Compare Card Fees.

What Is Square?

Square is a US-based payment and point-of-sale company founded in 2009 that launched in the UK in 2017. It provides a free card reader, a free POS app, and a suite of business tools covering inventory, staff management, reporting, and online store creation. Squareup Europe Ltd is authorised by the FCA as an electronic money institution (FRN 900846). Funds settle to your UK bank account the next business day with no fee.

Square's free plan is genuinely free: there are no monthly fees, no setup costs, and no minimum transaction volumes. Paid tiers such as Square for Retail Plus (from £49 per month) and Square for Restaurants Plus (from £60 per month) add features like advanced inventory and multi-location management. The main limitation is that Square is less suited to pure online businesses that need sophisticated developer tools or complex subscription billing. For a detailed look at pricing and hardware, read the Square UK review on Compare Card Fees.

PayPal vs Square: Features Compared

Payment Methods Accepted

Both providers accept Visa, Mastercard, and American Express. PayPal adds its own wallet as a payment method, which is a meaningful differentiator: buyers with PayPal balances or saved cards can check out in two taps, and this matters most for e-commerce. Square does not offer a wallet payment method. PayPal also supports Pay Later (Buy Now Pay Later) for eligible UK merchants, allowing customers to split purchases at no extra cost to the seller. Square does not currently offer a native BNPL product in the UK. For more background on BNPL options for merchants, see the guide to Buy Now Pay Later for UK merchants.

Hardware and Card Terminals

Square's hardware range is broader and more competitively priced at entry level. The Square Reader costs £19 plus VAT for the first unit. At £149 plus VAT, the Square Terminal is a standalone touchscreen device with a built-in printer. A customer-facing display comes with the Square Register, a countertop system priced at £549 plus VAT. PayPal's in-person hardware runs through Zettle: the Zettle Reader 2 costs £29 plus VAT for the first reader, and the Zettle Terminal costs £199 plus VAT. Both product lines are chip-and-PIN and contactless compliant.

Point-of-Sale Software

Square's free POS app is more feature-rich than Zettle's for bricks-and-mortar businesses. It includes real-time inventory tracking, employee timecards, customer profiles, and detailed sales reports, all at no extra cost. Zettle's POS is functional and straightforward to use, but its inventory tools are simpler and it lacks native employee management. If you run a shop with dozens of SKUs, Square's free tier handles this better out of the box.

Online and E-commerce Integrations

PayPal connects with virtually every major e-commerce platform. Shopify, WooCommerce, Magento, BigCommerce, and Wix all support PayPal checkout natively. Its Braintree gateway gives developers full control over the payment experience and supports card vaulting and recurring billing. Square integrates with WooCommerce, Wix, and its own Square Online store builder. The Square Online store is free to set up and lets you sell products immediately, which suits small retailers wanting a simple web presence without a separate e-commerce subscription. For a broader look at gateway options, see the guide to e-commerce payment gateways.

International Payments

PayPal is the clear winner for international sales. It supports transactions in more than 100 currencies and is available in more than 200 markets. Cross-border fees apply: typically 1.29% above the standard transaction rate for international card transactions. Square's UK operation is limited to GBP transactions settled into UK bank accounts. If a meaningful share of your customers are overseas, PayPal handles this far more naturally than Square.

Stripe vs PayPal vs Square: Where Does Stripe Fit?

Stripe sits between these two providers in terms of positioning. For online payments, Stripe charges 1.5% plus 20p per UK card transaction on its standard plan, which is significantly cheaper than PayPal's 2.9% plus a £0.30 fixed fee. A business processing £30,000 per month online would pay at least £870 in percentage fees alone with PayPal standard checkout, before per-transaction fixed fees, around £470 with Stripe, and around £445 with Square (both assuming about 100 sales). For in-person payments, Stripe Terminal hardware exists but is less developed than Square's product range in the UK. Businesses comparing all three should read the Stripe vs PayPal comparison and the Stripe vs Square comparison for a full breakdown.

Fraud Tools and Security

PayPal includes Seller Protection on eligible transactions, which can cover you against unauthorised transactions and item-not-received claims. This is a real operational benefit for online sellers. Both providers are PCI DSS compliant. Square uses machine learning fraud detection on all transactions and its dispute management portal is straightforward. PayPal's fraud tools are more mature given its 25-plus years of transaction data, but its account freeze policy is a known pain point. Accounts can be limited with little warning, holding funds for up to 180 days in some cases. For more on handling disputes, see the guide to disputing chargebacks in the UK.

Customer Support

Square offers UK phone support during business hours, live chat, and an email ticketing system. PayPal offers phone, chat, and a message centre, but its support quality for business accounts draws mixed reviews. Reaching a knowledgeable agent quickly can be difficult, particularly if your account has been flagged. Square's support is generally rated more consistently by small business users on UK review platforms.

Pros and Cons

PayPal Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Widely trusted checkout brand that can improve online conversion rates
  • Accepts payments in more than 100 currencies, making it strong for international e-commerce
  • Seller Protection covers eligible transactions against chargebacks and fraud claims
  • Buy Now Pay Later (Pay Later) available for eligible UK merchants at no extra cost to the seller
  • Braintree gateway offers advanced developer tools, card vaulting, and subscription billing
  • In-person rate of 1.75% matches Square's 1.75% exactly, so there is no fee saving either way

Cons

  • Online transaction fees at 2.9% plus a £0.30 fixed fee are high compared with Stripe (1.5% plus 20p) and Shopify Payments
  • Account freezes and fund holds are a recurring complaint. Funds can be withheld for up to 180 days during reviews
  • In-person POS tools through Zettle are less capable than Square for inventory-heavy retail
  • Customer support quality is inconsistent, and resolving disputes can be slow
  • Standard settlement takes one to two business days. Instant transfers cost an extra 1.5% per transfer

Square Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Square Reader costs £19 plus VAT for new accounts. That is £10 cheaper upfront than the Zettle Reader 2
  • Free POS software includes inventory tracking, employee management, and sales reporting
  • Next-business-day settlement to your UK bank account at no charge
  • No monthly fees on the standard plan and no minimum transaction volumes
  • Strong vertical-specific plans for restaurants, retail, and appointments

Cons

  • In-person transaction fee of 1.75% matches PayPal Zettle's 1.75% exactly, so there is no cost difference for card-present sales
  • No support for multi-currency or cross-border transactions. UK accounts settle in GBP only
  • Account stability issues exist. Square can close accounts with limited notice in cases of perceived risk
  • Online developer tools are less mature than PayPal's Braintree for complex integrations
  • Volume discounts are not publicly available in the UK. High-volume businesses need to look elsewhere

Which Is Better For...?

Small Retail and Hospitality Businesses

Square is the better choice for most physical retail and hospitality businesses. Its free POS software, next-day settlement, and vertical-specific plans for restaurants and retail give it a clear edge over PayPal Zettle for in-store operations. A café or independent clothing shop will get more out of Square's inventory and staff tools without paying a monthly fee. PayPal Zettle works well as a simpler option for lower-volume merchants who already have a PayPal account and want a card reader without setting up a separate system.

Online and E-commerce Businesses

The decision here depends on your priorities. PayPal's checkout button increases buyer confidence and its Pay Later option can lift average order values. However, at 2.9% plus a £0.30 fixed fee per transaction, the cost is high for volume sellers. A business processing £30,000 per month online would pay at least £870 in percentage fees alone with PayPal standard checkout, before per-transaction fixed fees, versus around £470 with Stripe. Square's online fee of 1.4% plus 25p per UK card transaction is far cheaper than PayPal's standard rate. Pure e-commerce businesses processing significant volume should compare Stripe and Shopify Payments before deciding. The payment gateway costs guide covers how to assess these options.

Mobile and Market Traders

Both providers work well for mobile traders who need a lightweight, portable card reader. The Square Reader at £19 plus VAT is cheaper upfront than the Zettle Reader 2 at £29 plus VAT. Both charge the same 1.75% in-person transaction rate, so there is no fee saving from choosing one provider over the other for card-present sales. For very low-volume traders, the cost difference is negligible and the choice comes down to which app you find easier to use. The market traders payment guide covers this in more detail.

High-Volume Merchants

Neither PayPal nor Square publishes custom pricing for high-volume UK merchants in the way that Adyen, Stripe, or Worldpay do. PayPal does offer negotiated rates through its enterprise and Braintree channels, but you need to contact their sales team directly. Square does not publicly offer volume discounts in the UK. Businesses processing more than £100,000 per month should use the Compare Card Fees merchant services comparison tool to obtain quotes from providers that offer interchange-plus pricing, which typically reduces costs significantly at that volume. The interchange-plus vs blended pricing guide explains why this matters.

Our Verdict

PayPal and Square each do one thing clearly better than the other. Square is the stronger choice for physical, in-person businesses. Its free POS software, next-day settlement, and competitive hardware make it hard to beat on value for retailers, cafés, and service businesses. PayPal is the stronger choice for online businesses that benefit from its checkout brand recognition, international currency support, and Seller Protection.

Both providers charge the same 1.75% in-person transaction rate, so the choice for bricks-and-mortar operators comes down to Square's more developed POS tools rather than fees. For online sales, Square's 1.4% plus 25p for UK cards undercuts PayPal's standard 2.9% plus a £0.30 fixed fee by a wide margin, and costs about the same as Stripe's 1.5% plus 20p.

The honest caveat on both providers is account stability. Neither PayPal nor Square operates a traditional merchant account. Both are payment service providers that aggregate merchants under a single account. That means your account can be frozen or terminated with limited notice if their risk systems flag your activity. For businesses where payment continuity is critical, a dedicated merchant account from a provider such as Worldpay, Elavon, or Barclaycard Business offers more contractual protection, even if the setup process takes longer. The merchant account vs PSP guide explains the key differences.

How Compare Card Fees Can Help

Compare Card Fees is a free, independent advisory service that has helped UK businesses find better card payment deals since 2012. If you are still unsure whether PayPal, Square, or a different provider is right for your business, use the Compare Card Fees comparison tool to get tailored quotes based on your actual transaction volumes and business type. There is no obligation to switch and no cost to use the service.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is PayPal or Square cheaper for small businesses in the UK?

It depends on where most of your sales happen. For in-person payments, PayPal Zettle and Square both charge 1.75% per transaction, so there is no fee difference there. For online payments, Square's 1.4% plus 25p per UK card transaction is cheaper than PayPal's standard 2.9% plus a £0.30 fixed fee. Work out your split of in-person and online volume before deciding.

Do PayPal and Square charge monthly fees?

Neither PayPal nor Square charges a monthly fee on their standard entry-level plans. Both operate on a pay-as-you-go basis with no minimum spend. Square does offer paid tiers, including Square for Retail Plus from £49 per month and Square for Restaurants Plus from £60 per month, which add advanced features, but these are entirely optional upgrades.

How quickly do PayPal and Square pay out to your bank account?

Square settles funds to your UK bank account the next business day at no charge. PayPal takes one to two business days for standard transfers. Instant transfers are available from PayPal but cost 1.5% of the transfer amount, with a minimum fee of 25p and a maximum of £15 per transfer.

Can I use PayPal or Square for my online shop?

Yes, both work for online selling. PayPal integrates with Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce, and most major platforms, and its checkout button is widely trusted by UK buyers. Square has its own free online store builder and integrates with WooCommerce and Wix. For high-volume online stores, Stripe or Shopify Payments are often more cost-effective than either provider.

Are PayPal and Square regulated in the UK?

Yes, both are regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. PayPal UK Ltd operates under FCA e-money authorisation (FRN 994790), and Squareup Europe Ltd is authorised by the FCA as an electronic money institution (FRN 900846). Neither holds a full UK banking licence, so your funds are not protected by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme in the same way as a bank deposit.

Which is better for a market trader or mobile business: PayPal or Square?

Square's reader is cheaper upfront at £19 plus VAT versus the Zettle Reader 2 at £29 plus VAT. Both providers charge the same 1.75% in-person transaction rate, so there is no ongoing fee saving from either. Both apps work offline and are straightforward to set up. For very low-volume traders, the cost difference is small and ease of use matters more than the fee gap.

How does Stripe compare with PayPal and Square?

Stripe charges 1.5% plus 20p per UK card transaction on its standard plan for online payments. That is substantially cheaper than PayPal's standard 2.9% plus a £0.30 fixed fee and about the same as Square's 1.4% plus 25p: Stripe is slightly cheaper below a £50 sale, Square slightly cheaper above it. At £30,000 monthly online volume, Stripe costs around £470 per month versus at least £870 with PayPal standard checkout, before per-transaction fixed fees. For in-person payments, Square's hardware range is stronger than Stripe Terminal in the UK. See the Stripe vs PayPal comparison and the Stripe vs Square comparison for full details.

What are the risks of using PayPal or Square instead of a merchant account?

Both PayPal and Square are payment service providers, not dedicated merchant account providers. That means they aggregate many businesses under a single account structure, which gives them the ability to freeze or terminate your account with limited notice if their automated risk systems flag unusual activity. Funds can be held for up to 180 days in PayPal's case during a review. Businesses that depend heavily on uninterrupted payment processing should read the merchant account vs PSP guide to understand the trade-offs before committing.

Trusted by 10,000+ UK Businesses

We’ve helped companies of all sizes, from local retailers to national ecommerce brands reduce their card processing fees without the hassle. Our clients process over £1 billion in payments annually through the UK’s leading providers.

Rated Excellent on Trustpilot

We’re proud of our reputation for honest, expert service. Check our latest reviews on Trustpilot to see why business owners trust Compare Card Fees.

No Sales Calls, No Pressure, Just Advice

We don’t share, sell, or misuse your information, ever. All enquiries are handled directly by our UK-based team. You’re in safe hands from the very first click.

Registered with the ICO (ZA666396)